Good evidence
Ceramides + Cholesterol + Fatty Acids
INCI: Ceramide NP + Cholesterol + Linoleic Acid · also physiologic lipid mixture, the 3:1:1 system, barrier repair lipids
The three lipid families that build the skin barrier, delivered together in a deliberate ratio. Individually they are ingredients. Together, in proportion, they are the barrier's own vocabulary.
Why it is here
The barrier's own vocabulary, restocked. The stratum corneum is built from three lipid families, and putting only one or two of them back turns out to be worse than none. The ratio is the point.
The stratum corneum lipid matrix is roughly half ceramides, a quarter cholesterol and a quarter free fatty acids, arranged in lamellar sheets. Deliver one or two of those and the sheets cannot assemble; the 1996 work found that single and paired lipids actually delayed recovery after damage. Deliver all three in an equimolar ratio and recovery is normal. Skew the ratio up to threefold toward one lipid and recovery accelerates. In older skin, the lipid to skew toward is cholesterol.
The receipts
Only equimolar mixtures of ceramides, cholesterol and free fatty acids allow normal barrier recovery, and further acceleration occurs as the ratio of any one of the three is increased up to threefold; similar preliminary results were obtained in damaged human skin.
Optimization of physiological lipid mixtures for barrier repair. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 1996. in vivo animal, n = murine skin, with preliminary validation in damaged human skin. PMID 8618046
The cholesterol-dominant optimal molar ratio mixture significantly accelerated barrier recovery in chronologically aged human skin at 6 hours, while the free fatty acid dominant version significantly delayed recovery in aged mice.
Optimal ratios of topical stratum corneum lipids improve barrier recovery in chronologically aged skin. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 1997. in vivo animal and human, n = aged hairless mice and aged human skin at 80 plus or minus 5 years, n equals 6 for the human arm. PMID 9308554
A ceramide-dominant physiologic lipid emollient substituted for the previous moisturizer improved SCORAD in 22 of 24 patients by 3 weeks, with parallel improvement in transepidermal water loss, stratum corneum integrity and hydration.
Ceramide-dominant barrier repair lipids alleviate childhood atopic dermatitis: changes in barrier function provide a sensitive indicator of disease activity. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2002. cohort, n = 24 children with stubborn to recalcitrant atopic dermatitis. PMID 12140465
What the study actually did
- Study
- Man MQ, Feingold KR, Thornfeldt CR, Elias PM. Optimization of physiological lipid mixtures for barrier repair. 1996.
- Journal
- Journal of Investigative Dermatology 106:1096-1101
- Design
- Controlled barrier-recovery experiments, transepidermal water loss as the readout
- Subjects
- Murine skin, with preliminary validation in damaged human skin
- Concentration
- Ceramides, cholesterol and free fatty acids in equimolar to 3:1:1 ratios
- Duration
- Recovery tracked after acute barrier disruption
- Outcome
- Equimolar mixtures restore normal repair; skewed ratios up to threefold accelerate it
In practice
- Typical use
- Roughly 2 to 5 percent total physiologic lipid, in a molar ratio around 3:1:1. Which lipid takes the 3 is the interesting decision, and the published answer depends on the skin: ceramide-dominant in atopic dermatitis, cholesterol-dominant in aged skin.
- Pairs with
- Glycerin, Squalane, Wax Esters, Niacinamide
- Keep apart from
- Layering a single-lipid product on top immediately after damage: the whole point of this system is that the proportion is the active. Adding a large excess of one lipid on top is exactly the manipulation that delayed recovery in the source papers.
- Cautions
- None notable. This is the skin's own material in the skin's own proportion. Slow rather than dramatic: the human barrier readouts in these studies move over hours for recovery rate and over weeks for clinical appearance.
Questions people ask
What does 3:1:1 actually mean?
A molar ratio of the three barrier lipids, with one of them present at three times the others. The 1996 study found that equimolar mixtures restore normal recovery and that skewing up to threefold toward any one lipid accelerates it. Which one gets the 3 depends on the skin: ceramide-dominant for atopic skin, cholesterol-dominant for aged skin.
Is a physiologic lipid cream better than petrolatum?
They work differently. Petrolatum is an excellent occlusive; it sits on top and slows water loss immediately. Physiologic lipids are absorbed and incorporated into the lamellar structure, which addresses the shortage rather than covering it. The 2011 vernix work found vernix and a petrolatum cream both outperformed no treatment. Occlusion and repair are complementary, not rival.
How long does barrier repair take?
The recovery-rate measurements in these studies run in hours after controlled damage, three, six and twenty-four hour timepoints. The clinical readouts run in weeks, with SCORAD moving by three weeks and continuing to improve out to twenty weeks in the atopic dermatitis study. So: measurable quickly, visible slowly.